I have had lots of responses to my request for stories and resources on my LJ (it's friends-locked and slightly filtered, which might mean people are more comfortable discussing things there). A lot of those responses have been from people who have (at this point) decided they are not trans but genderqueer or something else or not-a-woman-women, or have decided not to identify as trans. I'd ideally like some more responses from trans people, too, but I feel lucky to I have such a variety of people as friends! People are awesome (sometimes)!
*
I wanted to add something to what I wrote about in the last post, and it's something I kind of forgot before reading the responses to my LiveJournal post . . . I was reading with interest about people who have struggled with how they want to identify, and have come up as 'not trans', and I started to feel physically ill.
Living as a guy, surrounding myself with friends who accept me as a guy, being naked/less than fully armoured (no binder) around people who I trust not to read my body as female, being able to read my own body as a-certain-kind-of-male has meant that I don't often run up against feelings of intense dysphoria. I'm not ashamed of my body, it's not a bad body, it does most of the things I'd like a body to do - I'm very lucky. But reading these responses, started to wonder, what if I was told not to live as a guy? If I didn't have a large group of friends and acquaintances that accept me? If I didn't get read as a guy as often as I do?
I realised that actually the thought of not being trans/a guy myself was making me nauseous in a back-of-my-mind-familiar way. I felt queasy, and like i wanted to curl in a ball and cry, and my throat felt tight and panicky. So I guess that's a kind of dysphoria, and I suppose that's another thing that makes me trans.
*
Most of the time I don't quite remember, but it seems that my body remembers this queasiness from another time - over two decades of it sitting placidly just below the surface, almost like a second skin, so close and natural that I never thought it was anything but normal. And this morning (after a night full of bad dreams: clawing my way along chicken wire fences beside freeways in the dark and the rain, vehicles hurtling by close enough to touch, footpath on the other side of the fence) I woke up with a sense of relief - almost re-living that original moment of recognition.
I don't have to be female, I don't have to be a woman, it's OK, it's OK, it's OK.
Wednesday, December 03, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
"Most of the time I don't quite remember, but it seems that my body remembers this queasiness from another time - over two decades of it sitting placidly just below the surface, almost like a second skin, so close and natural that I never thought it was anything but normal."
Just reading this makes me shiver. Yes, that queasiness . . . once in a while, I get a physical "glimpse" of it somewhere in my body. Luckily, it doesn't stick around very long.
You know, I suppose in fairness I should add your blog to my list of readings that have influenced my identity; reading your experiences and your comments have helped me feel okay about calling myself trans in my head, and given me a little personal context -- because I feel that I know you even though we haven't met yet -- for my current feelings of disgruntlement towards my ovaries (which, granted, may be largely due to the fact that they're currently giving me cramps and bleeding, pardon my TMI).
So, uh, thanks. ::scuffs feet::
-gelasius
Hey, sorry if I contributed to the queasy. I was thinking as I was writing about how my story chimes with a particular transphobic/regulatory thing - the idea that it's possible to do masculinity within femaleness has been put to such coercive and transphobic use (you know, the existence of butch lesbians somehow disproves the existence of transmen...). And I'm struggling with how and when to talk about my stuff without repeating those coercive bits. So I'm sorry if I fucked up this time, and I'm so pleased you've got to a place where the queasiness isn't normal any more.
In conclusion, ::hugs::
just briefly - thanks to all three for your comments: you rock!
and ika, seriously, it's nothing you or anyone else has done, and it wasn't at all what i was expecting to feel (and if i had expected it, i still would have asked the same questions!) if anything, all of this discussion has confirmed to me that i am trans for a reason, so it's a good thing!
dear jon,
so...this is totally unrelated. but, remember me? it's ray. we met in melbourne over a year ago. we hung out at tea party and saw the best zombie sheep movie ever. it seems one of the most fun musicians ever has some aussie tour dates. check out myspace here: http://www.myspace.com/djjdsamson. i highly recommend this sweet booty-shakin' show. i hope you are doing well and maybe we can catch up? i think i still have your email somewheres. thinking of you! -rayden
RAYDEN!!! HI!!!
i'd love to catch up... are you gonna be in melbs too? unfortunately it looks like i will be away at the time that jd is going to be here, WOE! i will be in europe for 3 weeks. anyway, yes, please email me!
Post a Comment